Is Propane or Natural Gas Cheaper for Pool Heater?

When it comes to choosing between propane or natural gas for a pool heater, there are several factors to consider, including the upfront cost, ongoing fuel expenses, and overall efficiency. This comprehensive guide will dive deep into the technical specifications, cost comparisons, and DIY installation considerations to help you make an informed decision.

Upfront Cost Comparison

The initial cost of the pool heater itself is a crucial factor to consider. Propane heaters tend to be more expensive upfront, with prices ranging from $1,500 to $5,000 for a 150,000 BTU to 400,000 BTU unit. On the other hand, natural gas heaters are generally less expensive, with prices ranging from $1,500 to $4,500.

However, it’s important to note that the cost of installing a natural gas line and meter can be a significant expense, often costing upwards of $2,000 depending on your location. This additional cost should be factored into the overall upfront investment for a natural gas pool heater.

Fuel Cost and Efficiency

is propane or natural gas cheaper for pool heater

When it comes to fuel costs, propane is generally more expensive than natural gas. The current average price for propane is around $3 per gallon, while natural gas prices can vary significantly based on your location and local utility rates.

In terms of efficiency, propane heaters are typically more fuel-efficient than natural gas heaters. A cubic foot of propane can produce approximately 2,516 BTUs, while a cubic foot of natural gas produces only about 1,037 BTUs. However, natural gas burns at a higher rate, so you may end up using more of it to heat your pool adequately.

To illustrate the fuel cost comparison, let’s consider a scenario where a pool heater requires 100,000 BTUs per hour to maintain the desired temperature. With a propane heater, this would equate to approximately 39.7 cubic feet of propane per hour, or 0.39 gallons at a cost of $1.17 per hour. In contrast, a natural gas heater would require approximately 96.4 cubic feet of natural gas per hour, which at a rate of $0.50 per therm (100 cubic feet) would cost $0.48 per hour.

Efficiency and Temperature Considerations

Propane heaters are generally more efficient than natural gas heaters, with typical efficiency ratings ranging from 82% to 95%. Natural gas heaters, on the other hand, typically have efficiency ratings between 78% and 92%.

Another factor to consider is the performance of the heaters in different temperature conditions. Propane heaters may not work as well in extremely cold temperatures, as the fuel can become less vaporized, reducing the heater’s efficiency. Natural gas heaters, however, tend to perform consistently regardless of the outside temperature.

Heat Pump Alternative

One unique perspective to consider is the use of a heat pump, which can be more energy-efficient and cost-effective in the long run. Heat pumps work by transferring heat from the air or ground to the water in your pool, rather than generating heat through the burning of fuel. While the upfront cost of a heat pump may be higher than that of a gas heater, the ongoing costs can be significantly lower, especially in areas with mild climates.

Technical Specifications to Consider

When comparing propane and natural gas heaters, some important technical specifications to consider include:

Specification Importance
BTU Output Measures the heat output of the heater, a key factor in how quickly and efficiently the heater can heat your pool.
Fuel Efficiency Measures how efficiently the heater converts fuel into heat, a key factor in determining the ongoing costs of operating the heater.
Size and Weight Can be an important consideration, especially if you have limited space for the heater.
Ease of Installation Some heaters may be easier to install than others, which can be a key factor in determining the overall cost of the heater.

DIY Installation Considerations

If you’re considering installing a pool heater yourself, there are a few key things to keep in mind:

  1. Safety: Installing a pool heater can be a complex and potentially dangerous process, so it’s important to take all necessary safety precautions, such as wearing appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE) and following manufacturer instructions.

  2. Permits and Regulations: Depending on your location, you may need to obtain permits or follow specific regulations when installing a pool heater. Be sure to check with your local authorities before starting the project.

  3. Tools and Equipment: You’ll need a variety of tools and equipment to install a pool heater, including a gas torch, pipe cutter, wrenches, and other plumbing and electrical tools.

  4. Expertise: Installing a pool heater can be a complex process, so it’s important to have some expertise in plumbing, electrical work, and gas fitting. If you’re not confident in your abilities, it may be best to hire a professional.

By considering these factors and the technical details outlined in this guide, you can make an informed decision on whether propane or natural gas is the more cost-effective and efficient choice for your pool heater.

Bogleheads Forum Discussion on Propane vs. Natural Gas Pool Heaters
Leslie’s Inc. Article on Propane vs. Natural Gas Pool Heaters
Reddit Discussion on Natural Gas vs. Propane for Pool Heaters